Review of Detective-Themed Visual Novel, Best Served Cold PC

Best Served Cold is a stylish and atmospheric detective visual novel developed by Rogueside, released on PC 5 May 2025. Set in an alternate 1920s Europe, the game places players in the role of a bartender at “The Nightcap,” the last speakeasy in the city of Bukovie. As patrons come and go, players mix cocktails and extract secrets to solve a series of murder mysteries.

Narrative and Setting

The game’s strength lies in its rich storytelling and immersive setting. Each of the five cases unfolds through conversations with a diverse cast of 22 characters, each with distinct personalities and backstories. The dialogue is sharp and engaging, capturing the noir atmosphere of the era. The city of Bukovie is portrayed as a place teetering on the edge, with social unrest and looming war adding depth to the narrative.

Gameplay Mechanics

Gameplay revolves around serving drinks and gathering information. Players must choose the right cocktails to loosen tongues without overindulging patrons. While the drink-mixing mini-game is simple, it serves as a vehicle for the more compelling aspects of the game: the conversations and investigations. Players collect clues and piece together evidence to solve each case, though some have noted that the deduction mechanics can feel limited, occasionally encouraging trial-and-error approaches.

Visuals and Sound

Visually, Best Served Cold employs a hand-drawn art style that complements its noir theme. The character designs and backgrounds are evocative, immersing players in the smoky, jazz-filled ambiance of the speakeasy. The soundtrack further enhances the mood, featuring period-appropriate music that underscores the game’s tension and drama.

Reception

The game has been well-received, with a “Very Positive” rating on Steam, reflecting an 89% approval from users. Critics have praised its storytelling and atmosphere, though some have pointed out the simplicity of its mechanics. For instance, Checkpoint Gaming noted that while the gameplay is straightforward, the strong writing and world-building elevate the experience.

Final Thoughts

Best Served Cold offers a compelling narrative experience set against a richly detailed backdrop. While its gameplay mechanics are simple, the game’s strength lies in its storytelling, character development, and atmospheric setting. For fans of detective stories and visual novels, it’s a journey worth taking.